Deal Saver - brought to you by the Charlotte Observer

0 comments
  • Print
  • Reprint or License
  • Share Share

Local talent missing on Signing Day

By Andrew Carter
acarter@newsobserver.com

CHAPEL HILL Throughout most of the day on Wednesday, the video scoreboard that looms over North Carolina's Kenan Stadium showed the same highlights over and over on a never-ending loop.

It was National Signing Day, when college football programs celebrate their latest recruiting class, and that was the idea with the endless video montage - to celebrate and show off players who'd signed with UNC.

The Tar Heels welcomed a 23-man class that Rivals.com ranked the sixth-best in the ACC. Not too far away, at Duke, Blue Devils coach David Cutcliffe lauded his team's 20-man recruiting class, which Rivals ranked eighth in the league.

And down the road a ways to the east, N.C. State coach Tom O'Brien welcomed a 22-man class that he described as "long, tall and athletic." Rivals ranked the Wolfpack's class the ninth-best in the ACC.

In addition to the middle-of-the-conference recruiting rankings that each of the three local schools received, their signing classes shared at least one other trait: None of the local recruiting classes were filled with all that many local players.

Keeping in-state talent in North Carolina has long been a challenge for the state's Division I-A schools. It seemed especially challenging during the latest recruiting season.

Among the 10 prospects that Rivals considered to be the best in North Carolina, only one, Greensboro's James Summers, signed a national letter of intent to play at a North Carolina school. Summers, the quarterback who led Page High to the 4AA state championship, will play at UNC.

"We tried to make some in-roads on the in-state kids and we didn't have as much success there as I expected to have," UNC coach Larry Fedora said.

Of the 23 players in Fedora's first class at UNC, six are from North Carolina. The Wolfpack's 22-man class, meanwhile, includes eight in-state players. And at Duke, Cutcliffe's 20-man class is comprised in part of five North Carolina players.

Mass exodus

Both nationally and in the ACC, out-of-state schools built their recruiting classes with the help of some of the best prospects in North Carolina. Charlotte offensive lineman D.J. Humphries and Shelby defensive end Jonathan Bullard, the top two prospects in the state according to Rivals, both signed with Florida.

Tarboro's Todd Gurley and Keith Marshall, who starred at Millbrook, both signed with Georgia. They were ranked as the state's top two running backs.

"I don't think we'll be satisfied until we sign everybody in-state," O'Brien said. "That's the goal ... Continue to go to bowl games, continue to win, to put ourselves in a position to challenge and to go to Charlotte [for ACC title game], and that will increase our chances to keep a lot of the kids home."

Rebuilding 'the fence'

Mike Farrell, a national recruiting analyst for Rivals who focuses on recruiting in the ACC, wasn't caught off guard by the talent exodus from North Carolina. He has seen it happen over and over again, though perhaps not to extent as it did on Wednesday.

"I think it's just that there hasn't been a strong and consistent program in the state for so long," Farrell said. "You've had inconsistency with both of the big programs. It's up to North Carolina, especially, and N.C. State to keep these kids home." Among ACC schools, Florida State again finished with the consensus top class in the conference. ESPNU ranked the Seminoles' class as the second-best in the nation after Washington, D.C., defensive tackle Eddie Goldman, one of the top prospects in the country, announced his intention to sign with the Seminoles.

"I know when Mack [Brown] was here, there was a fence around the borders," Fedora said. "And it was hard to get a kid out of the state of North Carolina ... My job is to put a product on the field that kids in the state get excited about. Where a kid realizes, hey, I can reach every dream and goal I have right here on that field."

Staff writers Chip Alexander and Edward G. Robinson III contributed to this report.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.   Read more

Quick Job Search
Salary Databases