Deal Saver - brought to you by the Charlotte Observer

0 comments
  • Print
  • Order Reprints
  • Share Share

Police, protesters face off at Duke Energy meeting

First protesters -- a woman and 2 small girls -- arrive near the building about 9 a.m.

By Andrew Dunn, Cleve R. Wootson and Steve Lyttle
Staff writers

More Information

  • Police, protesters face off at Duke Energy meeting
  • Live updates: WCNC, Observer on Twitter
  • CMPD: We'll use reason with new protest law
  • Why exactly are protesters protesting?
  • Duke, BofA protests will test new city rules
  • Event boundaries

    • Duke Energy shareholders meeting: Limits will be in effect from 12:01 a.m. to 11:59 p.m. Thursday. The boundary limits are Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard on the north; South Tryon Street on the east; Stonewall Street on the south; and Graham Street on the west.

    Prohibited items

    Among items prohibited inside an Extraordinary Events zone:

    • Bars, chains, shafts, cables or plastic pipe capable of inflicting serious injury.

    • Containers or objects heavy enough to be used as projectiles, or containing objects that can be used as projectiles that could inflict serious injury to a person and damage property.

    • Paint guns, etching materials, spray paint containers, liquid paint, or markers containing a fluid that is not water soluble.

    • Backpacks, duffle bags, satchels, coolers, or other items carried with the intent to conceal weapons or other prohibited items.

    • A glass or breakable container capable of being filled with a flammable or dangerous substance, carried with the intent to inflict serious injury to a person or damage to property.

    • Sharp or bladed objects such as box cutters, utility knives, ice picks, or axes.

    • Masks or scarves worn with the intent to hide one’s identity while committing a crime.

    • Police scanners.



About 30 protesters gathered Thursday morning at the Duke Energy building in Charlotte’s uptown, voicing opposition to the company’s policies during its shareholders meeting.

The group, mostly Greenpeace members but also with a few Occupy Charlotte participants, chanted slogans opposing Duke Energy and complained about a new Charlotte city ordinance that puts limits on protests and the items that protesters can bring into pre-set “Extraordinary Zones.”

Meanwhile, another group of protesters said it had blocked a train carrying coal from reaching Duke’s coal-powered plant in Catawba County. Four protesters chained themselves to the tracks, organizers of the effort said.

And inside the meeting, at least one of the shareholders criticized Duke Energy CEO James Rogers and the company for its use of coal to power electricity-producing plants.

In the protest at the Duke shareholders meeting, no arrests had been made as of 11:30 a.m. The protesters chanted slogans, carried banners, and made speeches critical of Duke Energy policies, but a group of Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officers watched nearby and did not interfere.

CMPD officers had cordoned off a one-block area around the Duke Energy building early Thursday morning, setting up the Extraordinary Event zone.

The first protesters arrived about 9 a.m. -- a woman with two young girls, about age 6 or 7. The girls held signs, one of which read, “More renewable energy.” They said they had made the signs with crayons and were being permitted to stay out of school for an hour Thursday morning so they could lobby for Duke Energy to use more renewable energy.

More protesters arrived about 9:30 a.m., 90 minutes before the start of the shareholders meeting. Members of the group chanted “Dirty coal has got to go” and other slogans. One member of the group began speaking about 10:15 a.m., complaining about Duke Energy’s use of coal at its power plants and about Charlotte’s Extraordinary Events ordinance.

It is the first of several actions planned over the next few weeks, including an event at next Wednesday’s Bank of America shareholders meeting that could draw hundreds of protesters.

The city’s new Extraordinary Events ordinance permits authorities to limit protest activities and items that can be carried into a pre-announced zone. Earlier this week, City Manager Curt Walton announced that the zone around the Duke Energy building will be inside a quadrangle formed by South Tryon Street, Stonewall Street, Graham Street, and Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard.

The banner that hung briefly Wednesday from “Bank of Coal” stadium was the first of upcoming protests that, four months before the Democratic National Convention, will test Charlotte’s ability to police waves of demonstrators.

Aimed at massive targets – the nation’s third-largest utility, the second-biggest consumer bank and the Obama administration – the protests will serve as a convention tuneup for police and for activists eager to probe the limits of a new city ordinance regulating such events.

Protesters from across the country have stepped up their activities in the city since the Democratic convention was announced early last year, police Chief Rodney Monroe has told the Observer.

Police refine tactics, skills

Officers are already using such events, and others like the Fourth of July celebration uptown, to refine tactics for dealing with protesters and large crowds.

The 70-foot banner members of the Rainforest Action Network said they hung on Bank of America Stadium lasted less than 30 minutes Wednesday morning before Charlotte-Mecklenburg police pulled it down.

Police arrested five people: Robert Diesu, 24, of Washington, D.C.; Aleythea Dolstad-Lown, 26, of Vashon, Wash.; Benjamin Kessler, 28, of Round Rock, Texas; Samuel Maron, 26, of Atlanta; and Stephanie Taylor, 29, of Portland, Ore. Each is charged with misdemeanor breaking and entering.

“As we hone our skills, the consistency with which we respond, the way we communicate internally, it generally gets better as we go,” said police Major Jeff Estes, who is helping with convention planning. “A byproduct of that is speed. We honed our abilities to respond quickly to the ... trespassing at the stadium.”

Rainforest, the social-justice group Action NC, the N.C. Coalition Against Corporate Power and Greenpeace say they will stage “massive protests” against Duke and the bank at their shareholder meetings. An alliance of grass-roots groups called UNITY claims it will send 1,000 activists to Bank of America’s meeting.

Wells Fargo shareholders needed police to enter last week’s annual meeting in San Francisco as about 500 people protested the bank’s lending practices and foreclosures.

‘Very peaceful’ protests

The groups active in Charlotte say they will steer clear of violence. “Our events are going to be very peaceful,” said Roxana Bendezu, field organizer for the N.C. Coalition Against Corporate Power. “We just want a real good visual of people raising their voices.”

The groups held a news conference Wednesday to attack Charlotte’s new ordinance that expands police powers to stop and search people in or near protests.

The city manager has designated the Duke and Bank of America meetings “extraordinary events,” like the Food Lion Speed Street festival in May and July 4. That triggers a ban of potential weapons such as crowbars and even backpacks if police believe they carry weapons or “noxious” substances.

Julie Morgan of Action NC described limitations in the ordinance as “absurd.”

“Invoking this draconian law is another example of our democracy being sold to the highest bidder,” she said. “The city of Charlotte is protecting Bank of America’s bottom line. The Constitution and everyday people be damned.”

Duke, BofA targeted for coal

Duke has come under fire for its reliance on coal, a major source of air pollution, and for two rate hikes since 2009. Conservative demonstrators picketed last year’s shareholder meeting to protest CEO Jim Rogers’ role in raising money for the Democratic convention.

Duke says its critics fail to acknowledge the company’s efforts to retire its oldest, dirtiest coal-fired power plants and invest in cleaner technologies. Rogers says the DNC is good for the city as a whole, not just Democrats.

The Rainforest group says Bank of America has provided $6.7 billion in funding for the coal industry, citing data from Bloomberg financial news. The network is also unhappy with what it claims is a “cozy relationship” between the Obama administration and the banking industry.

President Barack Obama is scheduled to deliver his keynote speech during the Democratic National Convention at the stadium – part of the reason the protest group said it chose that site to hang the banner. In November, eight Rainforest protesters were arrested after scaling flagpoles in front of the bank’s corporate headquarters and dropping a banner reading “Not with our money,” and barricading an entrance to the building.

Bank of America has not commented on the coal activists’ protests. The bank has said that it finances many different types of energy projects, including “considerable” investments in renewable energy.

‘A dark precedent’

Greenpeace organizer Monica Embrey called the city’s new ordinance “a dark precedent for corporate greed and suppression of civil liberties.”

The group expects to be active at the Democratic convention in September, she said, and has “had a lot of correspondence over the last few months” with police.

Occupy Charlotte activist Scottie Wingfield said the group’s long relationship with individual Charlotte police officers has been cordial.

“That hasn’t stopped this kind of tactic of just little things to make things more difficult for us,” she said, “just little ways to assert their power and show who has the upper hand.”

Occupy members have been cited with jaywalking, she said, when other jaywalkers weren’t. The group says its members have been told not to wear scarves over their faces during marches.

Wingfield expects police to show restraint in enforcing the new “extraordinary events” ordinance – until the convention. “We can’t show our cards,” she said.

Staff writers Bruce Henderson and Meghan Cooke contributed.


Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.   Read more

Quick Job Search
Salary Databases
Your 2 Cents
Share your opinion with our Partners
Learn More