Sam Pride did not envision graduating with a degree in Afro-American Studies when he first stepped on to UNC Chapel Hills campus , but as the history buff from Rocky Mount searched for classes to take, an introductory course within the department quickly put him on the path.
That class, and the subsequent ones he took from the department, broadened his understanding of the world.
The curriculum did more than help Pride discover a part of American history that many have a hard time accepting, let alone understanding. It inspired him to start a mentoring program in which he and several other UNC students visit the C.A. Dillon Youth Development Center in Butner, a state facility for youths who have committed serious crimes, to talk about race, history and opportunities.
Many others who have graduated or taken numerous courses within the African and Afro-American Studies Department tell similar stories of enlightenment and inspiration. Thats why they are so disheartened by the scandal that originated within the small department and now has some calling for its end.
I worked as an undergrad, said Christina DeLane, a 2006 graduate now in a Washington, D.C., law school. I had papers to write, things to read, a lot of studying. It was several books in a class. This was real, and to think it wasnt real for other people is beyond me. You dont major in African and Afro-American studies to get by. UNC is a hard school.
A recent internal investigation of the department found 54 classes with little or no instruction over a four-year period, and dozens more independent studies with little accountability. Nearly two-thirds of the enrollments in the no-show classes were athletes, with football players representing the largest block.
The no-show classes are a small percentage of the 616 classes held in the department during that period. University officials say only two people in the department were involved in the suspect courses: Julius Nyangoro, the former longtime department chairman who was forced into retirement in July, and Deborah Crowder, the departmental manager who retired in 2009.
More evidence suggests the no-show classes and loosely monitored independent studies went back years beyond the 2007 to 2011 period reviewed by university officials.
But Pride, DeLane and several other nonathletes interviewed by The (Raleigh) News & Observer who either graduated with degrees from the department or took a high concentration of courses say they knew nothing about classes that offered little instruction or academic rigor.
Everyone I talked to was shocked by it, said Rob Stephens, 26, a staff member for the North Carolina State Conference of the NAACP, and a 2009 graduate.
The graduates comments about the departments overall rigor raise more questions about who were the intended beneficiaries of the suspect courses. UNC officials have said the academic fraud is not an NCAA matter because nonathletes were in the classes and were treated the same as athletes. So far, the NCAA has agreed, though other investigations into the fraud continue.
None of those interviewed said they had Nyangoro as a professor, and some of them said they do not recall meeting him during their time on campus. Jason Warner, a 2006 UNC graduate who is now a doctoral student in African and African-American studies at Harvard University, said he defended his senior thesis paper before Nyangoro and two other professors, and was impressed with the department chairman.
I really remember him for his intellect and the questions he would pose to me, Warner said.
He and other graduates say the small department of roughly 25 professors and instructors has top experts in their fields who are also gifted teachers. One of them, Reginald Hildebrand, was one of five professors this year to receive the universitys top undergraduate teaching award. He and other department professors, however, have declined to be interviewed about the departments strengths and weaknesses.
A review of syllabuses shows courses with rich topics and extensive classwork. A syllabus for a 2006 class titled The African American in Cinema required reading several books, watching more than a dozen films, producing two papers and completing two exams.
University officials say the department also plays an important role in the universitys study abroad programs in Africa, and helps students doing volunteer work there in areas such as health care.
But the scandal has caused some people to say the department should be eliminated for being at the heart of the scandal.
Others such as Jane Shaw, president of the Pope Center for Higher Education Policy, a conservative think tank, have questioned the need for a separate department that specializes in African and African-American studies, fueling a debate that has gone on at other universities untouched by scandal.
With Chancellor Holden Thorps urging, the council on Friday passed with no dissent a resolution backing the African studies department and its mission.
The department has a new chairwoman, Eunice Sahle, and numerous reforms have been put in place to try to prevent a similar scandal. One planned change that might bring relief to the departments graduates who are now worried about the scandals impact on their careers is a new name that better reflects the range of the departments focus. It will soon be called the Department of African, African American and Diaspora Studies.
The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.
Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email firstname.lastname@example.org to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.Read moreRead less