Deal Saver - brought to you by the Charlotte Observer

0 comments
  • Print
  • Order Reprints
  • Share Share

Mayor Foxx: Streetcar critics use 'smoke and mirrors'

In annual address, mayor says streetcar extension vital for struggling areas

  • http://media.charlotteobserver.com/smedia/2013/02/04/17/58/1lbPfZ.Em.138.jpeg|319
    Jeff Siner - jsiner@charlotteobserver.com
    Charlotte Mayor Anthony Foxx delivers his state of the city address on Monday, February 4, 2013. Jeff Siner - jsiner@charlotteobserver.com
  • http://media.charlotteobserver.com/smedia/2013/02/04/17/58/KBEqu.Em.138.jpeg|224
    Jeff Siner - jsiner@charlotteobserver.com
    Charlotte Mayor Anthony Foxx delivers his state of the city address on Monday, February 4, 2013. Jeff Siner - jsiner@charlotteobserver.com
  • http://media.charlotteobserver.com/smedia/2013/02/04/17/58/MIl62.Em.138.jpeg|201
    Jeff Siner - jsiner@charlotteobserver.com
    Charlotte Mayor Anthony Foxx delivers his state of the city address on Monday, February 4, 2013. Jeff Siner - jsiner@charlotteobserver.com

More Information

  • Mayor Foxx's state of the city address
  • Editorial: Mayor’s pointed plea for our future
  • McCrory defends streetcar comments, denies meddling
  • Streetcar would extend to east and west

    The city has started preliminary construction work on a 1.5-mile streetcar line from Time Warner Cable Arena to Presbyterian Hospital. Former City Manager Curt Walton proposed building an additional 2.5 miles of streetcar line as part of his proposed $926 million capital plan.

    The streetcar line would extend to Johnson C. Smith University and along Hawthorne Lane. The full plan calls for the streetcar to operate from Rosa Parks Transit Center to the site of the old Eastland Mall. Steve Harrison


  • Property taxes for transit?

    Gov. Pat McCrory said one reason he opposes the city’s plan to build the streetcar is because it would be built “outside of the half-cent sales tax” and would use city property taxes. He said that would break an agreement with area voters in the late 1990s that all transit decisions would be made by the Metropolitan Transit Commission, the regional governing body for the Charlotte Area Transit System.

    In his speech Monday, Foxx said that argument isn’t correct.

    He said the city has used property taxes for transit since 1998. (That money has been about $19 million a year, as required by the General Assembly.)

    That so-called “maintenance of effort” fund was increased by about 3 percent. That helped the city finance the Lynx Blue Line extension, which is scheduled to open in 2017, Foxx said.

    Foxx also said that any future funding plan to build a Red Line commuter train to Lake Norman also would require property taxes. When McCrory was mayor, the MTC had endorsed a plan to build the Red Line in part by using new property taxes generated from new construction that was expected to spring up along the line. Steve Harrison



In his most pointed annual State of the City address, Mayor Anthony Foxx said streetcar critics – such as Gov. Pat McCrory – are using “smoke and mirrors,” and that some opposition stems from the train line serving low-income areas.

The streetcar has been the main sticking point in passing a long-term capital plan, which has stymied the City Council since June. Foxx said after his speech this has been the hardest year of his public life.

The mayor’s speech comes three days before council members meet for their annual budget retreat, which may be the third significant attempt in eight months to strike a deal.

Foxx, a Democrat, said the city of Charlotte is at a crossroads because it cannot grow its tax base through annexation of rural areas and has little room to build new suburbs. To keep the city healthy, Foxx said council members must invest in long-struggling areas such as Beatties Ford Road, Central Avenue and Independence Boulevard.

The $119 million streetcar extension, he said, will spark economic development.

He said that McCrory, the former Charlotte mayor, has interjected himself into the debate over the capital plan by saying the streetcar could derail $299 million in state funding for the $1.1 billion Lynx Blue Line extension. Foxx said last week that be believed McCrory threatened the city over the possible loss of transit funding if it moved forward with building the streetcar.

In his speech, Foxx said the city wants to partner with leaders in Raleigh.

“However, we reject ‘help’ inconsistent with local priorities and any effort to perpetuate the so-called ‘culture of intimidation,’” Foxx said in his speech.

That was a comment aimed at McCrory, a Republican.

In an interview with the Observer Saturday, McCrory said he was giving the city “helpful advice” about how some legislators view the streetcar.

Four years ago, during his first run for governor, McCrory said there was a “culture of intimidation” in Raleigh, with mayors afraid to criticize the N.C. Department of Transportation; some local Democrats said McCrory was practicing what he once criticized.

Talk in Raleigh

In his speech, Foxx said: “In fact, in the backrooms of Raleigh, there appears to be a serious conversation about removing city control over the Charlotte Douglas Airport, eliminating revenues we count on to pay for police and firefighters, and cutting off transit funds. That’s wrong.”

Some legislators have been reportedly discussing creating an authority to manage the airport, which is now a city department. Aviation director Jerry Orr has said an authority would be beneficial for the airport, but that he isn’t leading any effort to break away from the city.

An authority would have its own board, meaning the aviation director would no longer report to the city manager and Charlotte City Council.

Interim City Manager Julie Burch is against an authority.

Under the current system, the City Council must approve most airport expenditures and plans. But the airport’s success means council members usually take a hands-off approach, approving most airport items without discussion.

Foxx wants Chamber help

Foxx also called on the Charlotte Chamber to do more to support the capital plan, which originally totaled $926 million and required an 8 percent property tax hike.

“I got letters from the Chamber to support baseball. I got no letters to support the capital plan,” said Foxx, who is in his second term.

In response to Foxx’s comments, the Chamber released a letter from June stating its support for the “need for a Capital Investment Plan.” The letter said the Chamber is “strongly in support” of some parts of the plan and divided on others.

Foxx has previously stated that he wanted the Chamber to endorse the entire capital spending plan, rather than the general idea of having one.

The mayor suggested that opposition to the $119 million streetcar among council members and business leaders was due to “where it goes.” The full 10-mile streetcar route travels through mostly minority neighborhoods.

After the speech, Foxx said the issue “is much more complex than black, white and brown.”

“It’s income, history and perception,” he said. “There are people who live in Central Avenue and Beatties Ford Road who have as much ambition as someone in south Charlotte.”

The streetcar has been a divisive issue among council members and in the community. Six of 11 council members are against building the streetcar, or are wary of using property tax dollars to do so.

Only two council members attended Monday’s speech – John Autry and David Howard. Both are streetcar supporters.

The capital improvement program isn’t on the agenda for Thursday and Friday’s budget retreat, which will be focused on the upcoming year’s operating budget. It could be discussed, however.

During his speech, Foxx said the capital plan is more important than a new baseball stadium and football. The mayor was referring to talks between the city and the Carolina Panthers on taxpayers paying for as much as $125 million in improvements to Bank of America Stadium.

When asked after the speech whether Foxx would insist on a capital plan before allowing money for the Panthers to move forward, the mayor said “it’s not necessarily an either or.” That leaves the door open for financial help for the Panthers before a capital plan is approved.

Positives

The first half of Foxx’s speech focused on what he believes are positives in the city, such as higher housing prices, the city maintaining its AAA bond rating and an increase in the number of people with jobs.

He said that one lesson of Black History Month is that people who fought for equal rights “knew that equal opportunity and economic empowerment were both morally right and good economics.”

He later said: “If we were to hold the mirror to our city today, we should see that, for all of our strengths, we lack a galvanizing vision of our community.”

He said a 2006 City Council decision to raise property taxes allowed the city to hire more police, build new roads and invest in affordable housing.

He singled out a man in the audience named Carl Frank Caldwell, who Foxx said was a former teacher who now lives at Moore Place, a new housing project for homeless residents.

“Because the city invested in Moore Place, Carl...has found his dignity again,” Foxx said. Staff writer Ely Portillo contributed to this story.

Harrison: 704-358-5160

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.   Read more

Quick Job Search
Salary Databases
Your 2 Cents
Share your opinion with our Partners
Learn More