Deal Saver - brought to you by the Charlotte Observer

In My Opinion

0 comments
  • Print
  • Order Reprints
  • Share Share

Bonnell: NBA players union head Billy Hunter’s tenure characterized by needless fights

Average NBA player lost in fight for stars' benefits

Rick Bonnell
Rick Bonnell covers the Charlotte Bobcats and the NBA for the Charlotte Observer. You can reach him by email.
NBA Labor Basketball
Frank Franklin II - AP
Billy Hunter, center, has seen two lockouts over the course of his tenure as the NBA players union executive director. (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II)

It seems likely Billy Hunter will be out soon as chief of the NBA players union. A review of Hunter’s stewardship by an independent law firm found nepotism, conflicts of interest and an employment contract that might never have been approved by the player representatives.

Hunter’s tenure has included two lockouts by the owners that nearly cost two full seasons. He and NBA commissioner David Stern can be similarly ornery. Now both are in the final lap, with Stern planning to retire soon.

Stern’s successor, deputy commissioner Adam Silver, is less of a cajoler, more of a consensus-builder. I hope Hunter’s replacement represents a similar shift in approach.

I always found Hunter, a former federal prosecutor, in constant search for the next fight. He seemed to consolidate power within the union by demonizing the owners. While it’s natural for there to be tension between labor and management in any industry, Hunter thrived on needless conflict.

I remember Stern once wanting a change to the anti-drug policy that seemed pretty reasonable. Hunter wouldn’t concede the point without asking for a concession on some unrelated matter.

Stern appropriately responded that if the players’ reputation wasn’t as important to the union as it was to the league, then there’s something very wrong. The change in the drug policy eventually went through.

A union that represents millionaires is out of the ordinary, I know, but I’ve long questioned whether the players association does what’s best for the majority of its members. It seems an inordinate amount of time and effort is spent on how stars get treated, to the detriment of the middle-class NBA player.

I’m not suggesting free-agency rules aren’t a big deal. Careers are short, so each contract is crucial to a player’s earning power. But Tim Duncan or Kevin Garnett would be rich under any system.

Some of the league’s best teams have evolved toward a system where two or three players make most of the payroll for each roster and many of their teammates play for minimum salaries. That should concern the players union a lot more than whether Dwight Howard gets to sign for $20 million a season, instead of $17 million.

I remember during the first lockout asking a middle-class NBA player why he was sacrificing hundreds of thousands in lost wages to protect the stars’ earning power. He looked at me like I was crazy, so I said, “Just watch.”

Then the lockout ended and details of the new collective bargaining agreement came out. I highlighted some key points in the union’s favor, almost all of which focused on a handful of elite players’ compensation.

This player – a smart guy who eventually became an agent – looked up, gave me one of those “what was I thinking?” expressions and shrugged. That’s how I will remember the players union of the past 15 years.

Five passing thoughts on the Bobcats and the NBA:

• I get asked a lot if the Bobcats should try to trade for an unrestricted free agent-to-be, like Utah’s Al Jefferson or Atlanta’s Josh Smith. I don’t see how you could justify giving up anything of value without assurances that player would re-sign in Charlotte. Why would a star free agent give up the chance to explore the market in July?

• I was initially surprised to see Charlottean Stephen Curry going to Houston to participate in the 3-point contest at All-Star Weekend. But it sounds like if a West All-Star can’t play due to injury, Curry might get first nod as a substitute. It’d be great to see him make it to the big Sunday event.

• I get more amnesty questions as the trade deadline approaches. A reminder: Each team gets to do one amnesty waiver over the course of the current CBA and it must be a player who was on the roster before the end of the last CBA. The only applicable Charlotte contract would be Tyrus Thomas, and that couldn’t happen before next summer.

• You might recall the Bobcats get Portland’s first-round pick in June if it’s outside the top 12 selections. The Trail Blazers are bobbing right about at the cutoff point; through Thursday’s games, Portland had the 14th-worst record at 25-24.

• I hear the Bobcats are among many NBA teams keeping tabs on Greg Oden, the former No. 1 pick center looking to make a comeback from chronic knee problems. Oden will have a lot to consider; opportunity to play, opportunity to win, earning power. There’s even been a suggestion the Cleveland Clinic’s medical reputation works in the Cavaliers’ favor.

The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.   Read more

Quick Job Search
Salary Databases