With one glorious stroke, Max Baucus has made it possible for two of Americas more interesting politicians to play bigger roles on the national stage. Not to be churlish, but Ill take Ron Wyden and Brian Schweitzer over a dozen Max Baucii any day. Never has a politician done so much to lift the prospects of the republic simply by saying goodbye.
Is there a soul outside Montana who is mourning Baucus decision not to run for a seventh term? Baucus helped George W. Bush pass his big tax cuts in 2001, making him an accomplice in the biggest fiscal mistake of this generation, squandering the hard-won surpluses that Bill Clinton (with Newt Gingrichs help) had bequeathed.
Then weeks ago, Baucus kept a bad thing going by voting against the new budget crafted by Senate Democrats, saying it raised too much revenue (even though its taxes wouldnt suffice to cover what Ronald Reagan spent as a share of the economy decades ago). When talk turns to tax reform, Baucus, again, has repeatedly refused to concede that when the dust clears from any simplification or base broadening, revenue has to rise in an aging America. This is the fantasy of math and demography that Republicans persist in embracing.
His guiding principle has been to get re-elected, says one former Senate staffer, not to lead and to educate.
The Montana senator was the delayer-in-chief on President Barack Obamas health reform, persuading the White House to let crucial time pass in 2009 while he tried and failed to secure Republican Chuck Grassleys support. Baucuss pussyfooting gave the GOP an opening to demagogue Obamacare and move public sentiment against it. These are just the most depressing Baucus accomplishments that come to mind. A fuller indictment would toss in Baucuss opposition to the Dream Act and his vote against universal background checks for guns just the other day, even though Baucus surely knew he was about to step aside. A profile in courage Max aint.
But those who stand to gain by his departure are much more promising.
Start with Wyden, the Oregon policy wonk whos next in line to chair the Senate Finance Committee (his Democratic elder, Jay Rockefeller, has already announced hes not running again). On health care, Wyden is virtually the only politician who bangs the table about the obvious need to move beyond our archaic employer-based health-care system (something the president chose to ignore). He fashioned a bipartisan bill with then-Sen. Robert Bennett of Utah to do just that, and it garnered more bipartisan support than any other plan in 2009s toxic debate.
Wyden-Bennett offered an economically rational approach to universal coverage that blended progressive goals with business realities and a search for common ground. And I dont mean consensus in the usual Beltway, symbolic, puny step forward spirit, but consensus that would have produced major progress. But thats Wydens modus operandi. He looks for big problems to tackle in ways that honor both parties values. On Medicare he incurred his partys wrath by penning a compromise conceptual plan with Rep. Paul Ryan that pried little-noted concessions from Ryan on coverage and spending growth.
Brian Schweitzer, Montanas popular governor from 2005 to January of this year, would bring fresh spice and perspective to the Senate. Hes not just another lawyer or wealthy businessman. Schweitzer earned degrees in international agronomy and soil science before working on irrigation projects on five continents. He worked in Saudi Arabia and Libya, and speaks Arabic. His outsized personality and homespun style make him accessible and formidable.
Im the kind of guy that, when I see a broke-down pickup, Ill get out with my tools and try to fix it, Schweitzer told the Hill Tuesday. And I can tell you looking at Washington, D.C., from Montana, there is no bigger broke-down pickup than the Senate in Washington, D.C.
Sounds like the mans running. Well know in a few weeks.
So thank you, Max Baucus. Im sure Montanans have reason to appreciate your decades of service. But the rest of us can be forgiven for concluding that youre serving America best by finally retiring to that dream house near Bozeman.
Matt Miller is a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress.
The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.
Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email email@example.com to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.Read moreRead less