Millions of homeowners, in Charlotte and around the country, have received an unexpected message from their banks: Goodbye.
After years of collecting mortgage payments from as many people as they could, big U.S. banks such as Bank of America and Wells Fargo are scaling back. As servicing mortgages grows less lucrative, theyre selling the rights to do so in deals measured by the billions.
The buyers are specialty companies much less known to the public. And as the massive transfers take place, regulators have signaled they are concerned about a small but growing fraction of homeowners who report falling through the cracks.
Some have found their online accounts unavailable. Others have reported delays in receiving account numbers. The details of some promised loan modifications havent been carried through with the new servicer.
In Charlotte, one man said his short sale, arranged with Bank of America, wasnt honored after the mortgage was transferred. The home is now in foreclosure.
Tales like these have led the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and Conference of State Bank Supervisors to warn the industry theyll be paying close attention to how the handoffs work.
Mortgage servicers arent bracing for fines and penalties, industry watchers say, but they are investing more energy in making sure their data technology is up to speed.
Its something everybody in the business is paying serious attention to, said Don Lampe, an attorney with the Dykema law firm who represents financial institutions.
Both Bank of America and Wells Fargo said theyre working carefully with customers to make sure their accounts are handled correctly.
The loans new owners, too, have beefed up teams to respond to consumer complaints. But they say they have a track record of handling the vast majority of loans successfully.
Well have 2.5 million consumers that we service loans for, said Executive Vice President Marshall Murphy of Texas-based Nationstar Mortgage Holdings, which earlier this year bought the rights to service $215 billion in loans from Bank of America. Of course youre going to have some instances where the consumer has not had a great experience. Were trying to do all we can one, to minimize that, and two, to address the problems that do arise.
Big banks want out
Servicing large mortgage portfolios has become less attractive for big banks for several reasons. Proposed capital rules count mortgage servicing rights as riskier than they were before, meaning banks have to keep a greater cash cushion against losses on those loans.
At the same time, the cost of servicing has increased significantly. Five big banks, including Bank of America and Wells Fargo, now have to abide by a slate of several hundred rules mandated by a massive state and federal settlement. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau also has more stringent servicing standards going into effect next year.
Servicers have a tremendous amount of obligations now, said Keith Gumbinger, vice president of mortgage industry publication HSH.com. Its become a more burdensome opportunity.
But that way of doing business isnt new to the three primary companies doing the buying Nationstar, Ocwen Financial Corp. and Walter Investment Management Corp., which services under the name of its subsidiary, Green Tree.
Unlike the big banks, which set up their mortgage servicing operations to handle large numbers of people with minimal involvement, the specialty servicers were designed for just the opposite, with more one-on-one service, Sterne Agee analyst Henry Coffey said.
Bank of America has sold the top three companies at least $316 billion of its mortgage servicing portfolio since last June. Wells Fargo sold about $12 billion in a reverse mortgage portfolio, and executives have signaled that it might consider more. J.P Morgan Chase, Ally Financial, MetLife and others have done the same.
The shift is huge. Nearly $500 billion in mortgages have moved over the past few months, and one company estimates that as much as one-fifth of the $10 trillion U.S. mortgage market could ultimately change hands.
The specialty servicers taking on these mortgages are growing rapidly and stand to make hundreds of millions of dollars. The three primary companies increased their earnings more than $170 million last year as the sales began, and analysts following the industry are bullish on their prospects.
Nationstar doubled its servicing portfolio with just one Bank of America transaction.
Bank of Americas actions alone are creating a major shift in the market, Michael Drayne, senior vice president of government-owned mortgage bond backer Ginnie Mae, said in a Q&A distributed to stakeholders this month. We dont see this trend slowing down any time soon.
There have been problems
But regulators have grown concerned that customers information is being lost through all the technological transfers. All three of the specialty servicers rank in the top 10 of a database of mortgage complaints maintained by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and the number has been accelerating.
While I dont think there have been considerable problems, there have been problems, said John Prendergast, vice president of supervision at the Conference of State Bank Supervisors. Were trying to talk to the industry now, and clearly lay out our expectations on what they need to do.
He said he couldnt comment on legal actions that might be taken. But regulators have been cautioned by botched transfers in the past, he said.
A Charlotte man, who asked not to be named because he was embarrassed by the situation, said he had a short sale arranged with Bank of America on a rental property near Independence Boulevard.
His loan was then transferred to Nationstar, which re-started the short sale verification process. He said it ultimately was denied, and the house is now in foreclosure.
Customer service reputation
George Erdle of Charlotte said it took several months after he learned his mortgage was being sold by Bank of America to Green Tree for his account to be set up with the new servicer.
He said he still cant access his account online, and repeated calls to Green Tree havent borne fruit.
Its really been a pain, he said. Service, I give it an F.
J.D. Power and Associates ranked Nationstar and Ocwen at the bottom of its mortgage servicer ratings last year. Green Tree wasnt polled.
Expertise in business and excellence in customer service dont necessarily go hand in hand, Gumbinger said. The point of the servicer is to handle the loan for the investor. Does that necessarily mean youre going to get fantastic customer service or a sympathetic ear? No.
Ocwen, in particular, is known for heavy use of overseas employees, which can frustrate customers who have trouble communicating with those workers. About 40 percent of its office space is in overseas facilities, securities filings show.
Fitch Ratings has also expressed concerns about the companys offshore staffing approach, Ocwen disclosed earlier this year.
Similarly, Nationstar is seeking to quadruple its overseas workforce, from about 250 to 1,000, Wells Fargo analysts wrote in a research note.
Murphy, the executive vice president, said customers personal contacts will remain in the U.S.
Still, industry defenders say their negative reputation comes from the fact that they handle some of the countrys most troubled mortgages. The big banks in the business dont have stellar reputations in this regard, either.
Anytime you mention the word mortgage, or touch the word mortgage, theres risk, particularly in this environment, Coffey said. The open question has to be whos good at managing that risk and how much substance is there to the complaints.
I think the specialty servicers have proven that they know what theyre doing.
Dunn: 704-358-5235; Twitter: @andrew_dunn
The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.
Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email email@example.com to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.Read moreRead less