Pundits and politicians are already labeling President Barack Obamas apparent selection of James Comey as the next FBI director as politically shrewd and smart. But more importantly, Comey, a Republican, has the background, experience and integrity to be exactly the right person for the job.
The integrity part is already getting the lions share of attention, and thats nothing to sneeze at. Comey, deputy to Attorney General John Ashcroft in the George W. Bush administration, had the incredible moxie to say no to President Bush and his emissaries in 2004 as they all but demanded that the AG sign off on renewing a warrantless domestic surveillance program.
Comey told the Senate Judiciary Committee in 2007 of that standoff. The fascinating testimony has been shown repeatedly since Comeys name emerged last week as Obamas pick.
The testimony centered on the night of March 10, 2004, when President Bush ordered White House chief of staff Andrew Card and White House counsel Alberto Gonzales to get Ashcrofts signature to reauthorize the program. Ashcroft was in the hospital gravely ill, and Comey was acting attorney general. Still, Card and Gonzales arrived late at night, over the objections of Ashcrofts wife, seeking approval. Comey, alerted by the FBI, high-tailed it to the hospital to head off the move. When Card and Gonzales got there, Comey who had already advised that the program was illegal was present. Ashcroft refused to sign-off and said Comey was the attorney general anyway. Comey said no, and FBI Director Robert Mueller (who Comey could now succeed) backed him up. Both threatened to resign if the president proceeded as planned to overrule them. Bush backed down.
That incident cemented Comeys reputation as a person of rock-solid integrity, and gained him lasting fans among Democrats in Congress. And as a staunch Republican, who has supported and donated to Obamas opponents in the last two elections, he should have GOP support, too.
Crucially, he has the backing of law enforcers, particularly in the FBI. He is a former U.S. attorney who has worked on terrorism, corruption, and organized crime cases in the 1990s. Among those hes prosecuted? The Gambino crime family, Martha Stewart and those who bombed the Khobar Towers in Saudi Arabia in 1996. On many cases, he worked closely with the FBI.
Observers say his experience fits perfectly with the new FBI, which has moved away from being focused on domestic law enforcement to an expanded role as an international intelligence agency with agents worldwide. Comey will be able to corral the agencys widespread activities, concentrate it on the greatest security threats and ensure it operates lawfully.
The nomination still should receive the highest scrutiny. The American Civil Liberties Union rightly notes that while working under the Bush administration, Comey oversaw or approved some of its worst abuses, including techniques that experts say constitute torture.
Still, the sum of his lifes work points to an unwavering moral compass that the nations top law enforcement agency needs. His words in 2005 to the National Security Agency staff after he left the Bush administration serve to highlight that. He said it can be very, very hard to be a conscientious attorney working in the intelligence community because we are likely to hear the words, If we dont do this, people will die, If we dont collect this type of information, or If we dont use this technique, or If we dont extend this authority. It is extraordinarily difficult to be the attorney standing in front of the freight train.
But no must be spoken into a storm of crisis, with loud voices all around, with lives hanging in the balance. In the long run, intelligence under the law is the only sustainable intelligence in this country.
The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.
Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email email@example.com to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.Read moreRead less