WASHINGTON Republicans seem to be adopting the self-immolation tactics of principled martyrs. Of course, principled or not, youre still dead in the end.
At this stage in the second term of the president they couldnt defeat, Republicans seem more like stubborn children refusing to come out of their rooms for supper, while the alternative is going to bed hungry.
This simile is unavoidable in light of the Houses recent passage of a farm bill without any provision for food stamps the first time in 40 years.
Republicans argued that theyd prefer to deal with agricultural issues in one bill without the leverage of a welfare program. These two programs historically were tied together in the spirit of watch out now compromise. And, though food stamps certainly will be funded, probably at current levels, through some other vehicle, Republicans managed to create yet another partisan problem where none existed and opened themselves up for gratuitous criticism.
Was this really the right fight at the right time?
The wrong time would be in the midst of the politically life-altering debate on immigration reform. Again, congressional Republicans want to parse reform in pieces, excluding the 11 million or so immigrants here illegally, instead of dealing with reform comprehensively, as the Senate has done and as most Americans think necessary.
Republicans do have a point, in theory. Comprehensive bills are cumbersome and difficult to enforce. Democrats love big programs because they (a) often do great good, at least in the short term; (b) create great big, self-sustaining bureaucracies that are by nature self-propagating, and attract large constituencies of voters. This latter is Republicans chief objection.
But 90 percent of life is picking your battles and congressional Republicans keep picking the wrong ones. This is not true of all. Former Republican vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan, R-Wis., has joined Luis Gutierrez, D-Ill., to push comprehensive immigration reform.
This is also not to say that Democrats have it all right. Both sides are often dishonest and usually self-serving. Democrats are maddeningly disingenuous when they say Republicans are anti-immigrant and then lecture us about how this country was built by immigrants.
Likewise, Republicans are not shooting straight when they insist that the Senate bills path to citizenship is de facto amnesty. As paths go, its a 13-year pilgrimage along a precipice lined with bramble bushes taxes, fines and various hoops through which one must leap in order to stand in line. Hardly rose-petal strewn.
To the real point, many Republicans fear that allowing 11 million immigrants to become citizens essentially means 11 million more Democrats. This outcome wasnt pre-ordained, but given the tenor of recent debate, their fears are probably justified.
Republican intransigence is further compounded by the echo chamber of the Tinker Bell Coalition The Weekly Standards Bill Kristol and National Reviews Rich Lowry, who recently co-authored an editorial urging Republicans to drive a stake through the heart of immigration reform. These are the same two who also thought Sarah Palin would be the perfect running mate for John McCain.
What Republicans are selling appeals to an ever-diminishing market that doesnt even include allies in the business community. And their self-immolation may prove to have been nothing more than a bonfire of vanities.
The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.
Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email email@example.com to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.Read moreRead less