Only a secure team makes as few changes in the offseason as the Carolina Panthers did.
They retained their head coach, hired a general manager who declined to shake up his staff and promoted quarterbacks coach Mike Shula to offensive coordinator.
They either believe they have enough or were too tired to give up again and start over.
Owner Jerry Richardson is 77. He doesnt want to start over. He doesnt want to wait. As much as anybody in the organization, and probably more, he wants to win now.
Winning means making the playoffs. Colleague and friend Scott Fowler believes the Panthers will.
In Scotts world there is eternal optimism and eternal sunshine. There are no problems, only opportunities.
Ive visited Scotts world, and while it was ever so pleasant sunny and 78 degrees and populated by smiling men and women wearing colorful golf shirts I couldnt live there. I dont own golf shirts.
What does Richardson do if Carolina finishes 9-7? Nine victories wont get the Panthers to the playoffs, but it will be two games better than 2012. Does 9-7 save jobs? Or does it suggest that, while Carolina is gradually improving, it cant quite close the deal?
The Panthers could finish 9-7. They also could, as Scott predicted months ago, finish 10-6.
I see 8-8.
I realize they won their final four games of 2012 and five of their last six.
You realize that momentum ends when the season does.
Look. Carolina has the potential to improve. By the end of the 2012 season, Cam Newton was a quarterback, not an athlete, and his progression continued in training camp. He often looked past favored targets Steve Smith and Greg Olsen and found alternate receivers such as Armanti Edwards.
The offensive line probably is the teams weakest component. I trust some of the veterans but the younger and unproven players have not demonstrated they are legitimate NFL starters.
The Panthers will run more than they did last season and Cam Newton wont lead them in rushing. Jonathan Stewart should but hes out for awhile or indefinitely. If they cant run, how do they win?
Shula was promoted to offensive coordinator so Newton wouldnt have to learn a new offense. He has the continuity down. But does he have the expertise and creativity to be an offensive coordinator? Well know soon enough.
The defense will be better because of Star Lotulelei, whose last name, to my discredit, I still cant spell without going to the roster. A 6-2, 315-pound rookie defensive tackle, Lotulelei is a force. Opponents have to account for him. He could make a run at defensive rookie of the year.
If Jon Beason retains his health, he and Luke Kuechly and Thomas Davis will give the Panthers a smart, scrambling and disruptive group of linebackers. The defensive line was impressive last season. The Panthers have added defensive backfield depth. But did they find starters?
The offenses of NFC South rivals Atlanta and New Orleans are loaded. Do the Panthers have enough playmakers to win the close games theyve failed to? I dont see it.
I hope Scott is right. A run to the playoffs would light up Charlotte, Rock Hill, Raleigh and every other place fans of the Panthers tread.
If they go 11-5 Ill buy golf shirts mauve, taupe and lavender.
But I believe my wardrobe is safe.
The Panthers are one of the many, neither terrible nor outstanding. Theyll be better. They wont be good enough.
The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.
Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email email@example.com to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.Read moreRead less