Argumentative child needs instructions, not sugestions |


Family psychologist John Rosemond answers parents' questions on his website at

Argumentative child needs instructions, not sugestions

01/14/14 01:41

Q: What suggestions do you have for disciplining a 7-year-old girl who argues with every single thing her parents say? We don’t try to reason with her and we frequently say “Because I said so” but she seems absolutely incapable of simply doing what we tell her to do. This is driving us to the brink of insanity! Thank you for any suggestions.

A: I don’t have suggestions. I have a solution. But first, children argue because parents explain. This is slightly different from trying to reason with a child, so bear with me.

Today’s parents – and of course I speak generally – feel some need to be egalitarian with their children. One unconscious symptom of this is the habit many parents have of stooping down to child level when they give instructions. The position suggests that parent and child are peers. It also looks as if the parent is pleading with the child as opposed to speaking authoritatively.

A second symptom is the tendency of today’s parents to give passive instructions along with explanations, as in “Honey, it would really be helpful if you would stop what you’re doing and pick these toys up for Mommy so I can vacuum this room.” In this example, the instruction isn’t an instruction at all. It’s a suggestion.

Furthermore, the explanation invites push-back, also known as argument. The child shouts, “I was here first and why can’t you vacuum later and you always want me to move my stuff!”

Train yourself to give instructions (a) from an upright position and (b) without explanations, as in, “I want you to pick up these toys and move them to another room.” When the child whines, “But why?” answer with “Because I said so.” Calmly, mind you, as if you’re answering “What’s the weather like outside?” And then turn and walk away. Pull the plug on the power struggle.

As for your daughter’s arguing, she’s going to need a consequence to help her focus on the new way of doing things. Tell her a parenting expert told you that arguing means she’s too tired to remember her manners, and so every time she argues, she has to go to bed 30 minutes earlier that evening. Enforce this dispassionately and within a couple of weeks, you should be further back from the brink of insanity than you have been in several years.

The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.

Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.

  Read more