The Next Big Scene
By Keia Mastrianni | Photography by Sean Pressley
Posted: Tuesday, Jan. 21, 2014
Weve come a long way from being a strictly steakhouse and chain restaurant town. From food trucks to city markets, the Queen City is starting to leave behind its conservative culinary roots in favor of an increasingly vibrant dining scene. Thanks to innovative chefs, adventurous events, and curious palates, Charlotte is a city on the verge.
Over the last ten years, Charlottes population has grown by nearly 200,000 peopleand the city has moved swiftly down a long list of big city to-dos. From building world-class art museums on our uptown streets to hosting national conventions, from new stadiums and greenway additions to a growing list of big businesses that call Charlotte home, this is a city willing to invest in its future.
But Charlottes food scene has seemed to follow the fate of our notoriously fickle weather, toggling between hot and cold. There have been times of steady momentum and gleaming shimmers of creativity followed by years of what some call complacency. As Kim Severson wrote in a 2012 New York Times article, Charlotte is a city still figuring out what kind of food town it wants to be.
This has often meant exclusion from the national spotlight when it came to listing great Southeastern food cities like Charleston, Atlanta, Nashville, and even recently, Asheville. Charlotte has frequently been oversimplified into the stale moniker of a meat-and-potatoes banking town.
A banking town fundamentally doesnt want to take risks, says Patrick Whalen, partner at MAP Management, the restaurant group that burst onto the scene in 2012 with 5Church and most recently, Nan and Byrons in South End. They want a corporate guarantee.
But change is coming. New restaurants like MAP Managements are rapidly arriving, creative chefs are testing local palates, and regional farms are gaining momentum. A discussion among Charlottes culinary leaders reveals a nascent desire to break out of the buttoned up stigmaand a real sentiment that with new developments this year, we are on the cusp of a culinary tipping point.
YOUVE COME A LONG WAY, CHARLOTTE
September 8, 1978, may have been the most pivotal date in Charlottes dining history. Thanks to its unique position as the buckle of the Bible Belt, Charlotte restaurants had not been legally allowed to sell liquor before the mixed drink referendum passed that year. The 1980s firmly placed the city on the national map as a banking center and by the 90s, that momentum had brought talented chefs like Bruce Moffett, Tom Condron, Gene Briggs, Mark Hibbs, and Tim Groody.
In addition to these chefs delivering inventive, locally inspired cuisine in their respective restaurants, in 2004 Johnson & Wales established its Charlotte campus and we landed our first upscale steakhouse when Mortons came to town. The following year, we welcomed a professional football team, and expense accounts knew no bounds.
Between 1994 and the recession of 2008 Charlotte had two Ruths Chris, two Mortons, a Palm, Sullivans, Flemings, Chima Brazilian Steakhouse, Capital Grille, Del Friscos, and McIntoshs in addition to a plethora of locally owned steak and chop houses.
But, the city also had independent chefs like Tim Groody connecting to the local food scene and building relationships in community, namely with farmers. According to Chef Gene Briggs of uptowns Blue restaurant, the recession of 2008 really changed things in Charlotte, especially for the independent chef. People stopped using farmers as much, they started playing it safe, says Briggs. People were more careful with their money and when they did go out, they went to places that were more safe to them.
Almost two years ago, Patrick Whalen and his partners Alejandro Torio and Mills Howell took a chance on a 6,000-square-foot space that was written off by most restaurateurs and deemed impossible to operate. That space now houses 5Church, one of Charlottes most lauded restaurants. According to Whalen, most spaces that big are given to corporate establishments because landlords are not willing to take the risk on locally owned places.
We havent made the investment in each other, says Kris Reid, executive chef at Southminster and charter member of the Piedmont Culinary Guild, a newly formed organization looking to build community among chefs, farmers, resources, and the community at-large. A small restaurant cant afford 30 percent food cost and pay thousands of dollars per square foot to operate in uptown.
Reid feels that that those with financial resources must be willing to invest in the food scene, which means initially shifting focus from the bottom line, and therein lies the struggle. Charlotte is beholden to a conservative mentality that manages risk like a banking town ought to, and often chooses the tried and true (read: the corporate guarantee) over something unexpected, different, and locally grown.I think we have rock star chefs in this town. I just dont think they have the resources to bring their ideas to fruition, says Reid. She points out the vibrant food scene in Durham, nonexistent four years ago, that now flourishes because people were willing to stake a claim and financially back culinary talent and support a local food culture.
The palate of consumers often gets the same rap, chided for erring on the conservative side. Thats the thing I hear the most, says James Yoder, a self-proclaimed foodie and owner of Not Just Coffee. That Charlotteans dont want that and I dont think thats the case.
Yoder believes the desire for more from Charlottes food scene is there. His craft coffee shop, which specializes in pour-over coffees and handcrafted espresso drinks, is a perfect example. You would not believe how many people told me good luck, but thats not going to work in Charlotte, he says. I just dont buy that If youre really passionate about bringing good food and that element of culture to a city, then I think that necessitates the risk.
But food isnt the only culinary aspect thats gaining momentum quickly in Charlotte. The citys fast-growing craft beer scene is creating a positive shiftboth at the bar and in the minds of Charlotteans. People who were drinking Bud Light are now drinking craft beer, says Courtney Lynch, bar maiden at NoDa Brewing Company and co-founder of The Cheshire Dinner Society, a local underground supper club. Lynch feels the same can happen around food.
I think its going to take two or three separate restaurateurs to develop something together, says Lynch, whose events have included an intimate dinner in the basement room at Leroy Fox and an upscale evening at Halcyon. Doing that on a neighborhood scale could really start something. We need smaller big ideas.
A similar model to Cheshire has found great success in enhancing the dining in Asheville. Through its themed charity dinners, Blind Pig Suppers has been able to push the bounds of creativity on the plate, create solidarity among chefs, and gardner national attention for the citys culinary scene.
What Id like to see is a lot of smaller independent restaurants and more diversity, says Augusto Conte, veteran restaurateur (Luce, Coco Osteria, Toscana) and recent recipient of the Pat McCrory International Entrepreneur Award. We dont need any bigger chains, we have plenty of that.
MONEY ON THE TABLE
While independent restaurateurs and inventive event planners are crucial, there are strategic moves to be made and support to be given when it comes to creating a thriving scene. Chef Bruce Moffett of Barringtons, Good Food on Montford, and the new Stagioni, believes that the effort must come from the city itself. He cites the burgeoning restaurant scene in Greenville, S.C. as an example. They said an independent restaurant scene was important and they worked toward promoting it and making it a priority, says Moffett.
Less than 10 years ago, there was no culinary scene in Greenville. Thanks, in part, to aggressive civic planning and revitalization efforts, the arrival of big business and nationally recognized festivals like Euphoria, there are now 110 independently owned restaurants along a mile and a half stretch of Main Street.
Over the last year, Charlotte too has shown signs of supporting its own. The Competition Dining Series, Fire in the City, brought Charlotte chefs together for 15 head to head battles where they competed in front of hungry audiences using a secret local ingredient in three courses. The event sold out in three weeks.
Heidi Billotto, official blogger for the Fire in the City competition and Charlotte resident since 1975 says people are starting to get it. The interest is calculable simply by looking at her food blog, Heidi Billotto Food. Launched just before the Competition Dining series began, within two months the site posted 2,500 unique monthly visitors. I think now we need to hold our heads high and continue to promote ourselves, says Billotto.
That promotion should be a conscious effort toward developing standards in Charlotte, according to Joel Tracey, founder of Culture Initiative and co-founder of The Cheshire Dinner Society. I think we have to work in really driving people to the places that are doing it right and delivering a great experience, says Tracey, who is currently working on a project called Lucky Fork, which vets independent restaurants by tapping into the restaurateurs, chefs, and industry insiders to handpick forward-thinking establishments to bear the Lucky Fork decal on their front windows.
Tracey is also a charter member of the Piedmont Culinary Guild and helped coin the motto for the organization, All Ships Rise, a theme that comes up time and again in conversation with Charlottes food community. The idea behind the mission is that through collaboration, support, and genuine connections, everybody succeeds together.
And, of course, the community goes far beyond restaurants. A look at the great food cities of the world will show areas rich in diversity, from the small mom-and-pop joints to the chef-driven concepts worthy of the national spotlight. These are often in neighborhoods teeming with shops and eateries, easily accessible by foot. And these cities have vibrant street food cultures, artisans, and fresh markets with local produce. Most importantly, they have a customer base with the resources to support the evolution of the food culture. Charlotte has all these thingsalong with an ambitions motivation for growth.
Here, veteran chefs continue to reign in spots like Briggs Blue, which just celebrated a decade of business and signed a ten-year lease. Meanwhile, Chefs Bruce Moffett and brother Kerry Moffett opened new Italian concept, Stagioni, and Tom Condron and business partner Matthew Pera have a second concept, Lumiere, open now in Myers Park.
New chefs are stepping onto the scene creating stronger links to farms and bringing a fresh perspective on local cuisine. Chef Paul Verica opened Heritage in Waxhaw last December, Chris Coleman launched a modern southern concept in the Dunhill Hotel, and Chef Luca Annunziata is bringing his hyperlocal cuisine to Elizabeth. Creative minds work inside the 51 food trucks roaming around Charlotte, a non-existent scene before 2009. Artisans fill the space at Seventh Street Market and and palates are becoming ever more curious as evidenced by the infiltration of competitions, food tours, and specialty dinners.
We have an entire city culture thats collectively caring about the progress of the city forwardand thats incredibly positive, says MAP Managements Patrick Whalen. Now, its about trying to shake off the roots of mediocrity when it comes to the culinary scene and take some risks, invest in local groups, and start getting excited about local people.
The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.
Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email firstname.lastname@example.org to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.Read moreRead less