A friend suggested recently that his and my 10-year-old boys go to a Charlotte Knights game. We would drop them off at the gate, give them some cash for concessions and leave them a cell phone, just in case. I wasnt so sure.
If youre of a certain age say, you remember 8-track tape players in cars this is where you get to shake your head at the state of modern parenting. Its where you remember how your 10-year-old self got to ride a bike across town, or how you sat in the back of your parents station wagon without a seatbelt, or how some cars didnt have any seatbelts and you still survived.
Debra Harrell probably agrees with you. Or maybe she has little choice but to agree.
Harrell is a 46-year-old single mother in North Augusta, S.C. This month, she let her 9-year old daughter play at a park while she worked her shift at a nearby McDonalds. Harrell gave her daughter a cell phone, just in case, and for two days the girl played among the dozens of kids there at any given time.
On the third day, when the girl told an inquiring adult that her mother was at work, the adult called police, who arrested Harrell for unlawful conduct toward a child. Social Services officials took custody of the girl.
You can guess what came next. The arrest, critics howled, is helicopter parenting gone mad. Its an indictment of a society so fearful especially with our children that were paralyzed by the worst-case-scenarios we imagine.
The law, by the way, is pretty vague on this. In South Carolina, as in most states, statutes dont specify at what age a child doesnt need supervision. Nine years old may be on the bubble, but had it been against the law in 1974 to leave a child that age alone in a public space, half of Americas moms would have been fingerprinted like Harrell.
But theres another, bigger dichotomy going on here not between past and present, but between the different worlds we live in now.
If my friend and I had sent our 10-year-olds to a Knights game, and if a concerned parent had reported the unsupervised boys, the police probably wouldnt have come to the Charlotte Observer or his bank office and arrested us. Even if they disagreed with our parenting decision, they likely wouldve considered our right to calculate safety and responsibility and growing up. The worst we wouldve received, probably, was a warning.
Debra Harrell didnt get that consideration, and we shouldnt be surprised. Because most everything is harder when youre poor. Its hard to find a path to a living wage. Its hard to find child care you can afford. Its hard to get others to believe youre trying.
Yes, you can argue that some willingly put themselves in that world although Harrell herself seemed to be trying to work her way out. But once youre there, its difficult to get anyplace else, and the hardest part of all may be this: Because people believe its your fault, and because its become so acceptable to bash the poor, all of your decisions are seen through that lens.
So instead of considering that Harrell may have thoughtfully weighed what responsibility her child could handle, instead of entertaining that Harrell decided the park was safer than a car or a home farther away, police concluded that thoughtfulness must have given way to desperation.
And instead of the statistical fantasy of being abducted in a place full of parents and kids, Harrells 9-year-old girl now has experienced the very real trauma of being taken from her mother and threatened with foster care. Because children, after all, should be protected.
The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.
Have a news tip? You can send it to a local news editor; email firstname.lastname@example.org to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Charlotte Observer.Read moreRead less