In My Opinion

  • Print
  • Reprint or License
  • Share Share

N. Carolina offense just offensive

By Caldon Tudor
Raleigh News & Observer
Caulton Tudor has worked for The News & Observer or The Raleigh Times for more than 30 years.

CHAPEL HILL A Champs Bowl dude was in the house Saturday at Kenan Stadium.

That's the late-December game in Orlando, Fla., which usually winds up getting a couple of 7-5, maybe 8-4, teams from the ACC and the Big Ten.

But based on everything that unfolded in Virginia's 16-3 win against North Carolina, the scouting trip might have been a waste of money. There's no compelling reason to assume either team will escape this football season with more wins than losses.

In Virginia's case, that's not unexpected. The Cavaliers began amid low expectations and had lived down to them through three straight losses.

But for North Carolina, now 3-2 after successive flops against Georgia Tech and Virginia, the season is turning into the sort of embarrassing shock that led fans to boo coach Butch Davis and his offensive staff during both halves Saturday.

Those boos, though limited to isolated sections, were richly deserved, too.

Sure, there have been some pivotal injuries. Sure again, several key offensive players are inexperienced.

But bottom line - as Davis puts things occasionally - there's no reason in the world for North Carolina failing to score a touchdown (or even seriously threaten) against a winless visiting team that had given up 26 points to William & Mary, 30 to Texas Christian and 37 to Southern Miss, the team Alabama-Birmingham routed a couple of days ago.

North Carolina's offense reeked from the word "hike." The blockers were confused and smothered by a 3-4 defense Virginia has been running all season but apparently struck the Tar Heels as something from deep outer space.

Since no one could block, no one could run, although backup Ryan Houston was big and mad enough to average 5.3 yards on three carries through sheer size and determination.

Houston didn't have a big role in the game plan, but at least he got on the field. The same can't be said for substitute quarterbacks Mike Paulus and Braden Hanson, who watched along with everyone else as T.J. Yates struggled yet again.

Yates said after the game that he didn't think Davis and offensive coordinator John Shoop would turn to a reliever. Yates was right.

"We're in the situation where you sometimes have to play your way through some bad performances," Davis said. Yates "didn't play as well as we'd have liked for him to last week at Georgia Tech. He hit some throws today, but he was under duress. ... They blitzed or pressured something in the neighborhood of 10 of the first 19 plays."

Yates, an experienced junior, threw for 135 yards and was intercepted twice, running his season total in that department to seven. That he's a bright, tough, determined youngster who's dedicated to the program isn't in doubt. But it's equally clear Yates, in three of the five games, has floundered. Whether it's his fault or not, the rest of the offense has followed suit.

The overriding story of North Carolina football, dating to the early 1950s, has been an eternal search for quality quarterbacking. It's a problem that has befuddled every coach from Jim Tatum to Davis and led directly to the eventual release of some.

Davis is beginning to track in a dangerous direction on that front, too. The economy is tight and his contract is a big, long one. But at a time when the school is planning yet another multimillion-dollar stadium expansion, nothing can undercut program interest more than a sterile offense.

Davis and Shoop are committed to Yates. That much was apparent a year ago when they benched hot-handed Cam Sexton for Yates, who was returning from injury, going into a game at Kenan Stadium against N.C. State. The result was a 41-10 disaster that left both camps howling - one in protest, the other in delight - and opened the door for Sexton to transfer.

The coaches are getting paid fortunes to make the best possible decisions for the program. They think Yates is the way to go, and maybe they're correct. But for now, it's just not working well enough to rule out alternative measures.

caulton.tudor@newsobserver.com or 919-829-8946

The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.   Read more

Disclaimer