• Print
  • Reprint or License
  • Share Share

Emotions run high at town hall meeting

Foes, backers of health care overhaul speak out at Myrick-hosted event.

By Jim Morrill
jmorrill@charlotteobserver.com
  • http://media.charlotteobserver.com/smedia/2009/08/26/00/180-Myrick townhall 0826.ART0_G26NU9LS.1+myrick_townhall_09.JPG.embedded.prod_affiliate.138.jpg|262

    Cille Richardson of Wesley Chapel makes a point at Rep. Sue Myrick's town hall meeting at Weddington High School in Union County. An overflow crowd of 1,200 attended.

  • http://media.charlotteobserver.com/smedia/2009/08/25/23/556-Myrick townhall 0826.ART0_GJTNTSFF.1+myrick_townhall_20.JPG.embedded.prod_affiliate.138.jpg|209

    Members of the audience hold up signs before Rep. Sue Myrick's remarks Tuesday at a town hall meeting in Weddington. Many objected vehemently to President Obama's proposed health care overhaul.

  • http://media.charlotteobserver.com/smedia/2009/08/25/23/292-Myrick townhall 0826.ART0_GJTNTSFF.1+myrick_townhall_01.JPG.embedded.prod_affiliate.138.jpg|423

    Pelletier

  • http://media.charlotteobserver.com/smedia/2009/08/25/23/644-Myrick townhall 0826.ART0_GJTNTSFF.1+myrick_townhall_03.JPG.embedded.prod_affiliate.138.jpg|449

    Hopper

  • http://media.charlotteobserver.com/smedia/2009/08/25/23/335-Myrick townhall 0826.ART0_GJTNTSFF.1+myrick_townhall_06.JPG.embedded.prod_affiliate.138.jpg|477

    Kincaid

More Information

  • Read the health care bills
  • Today: 7 p.m., J.V. Washam Elementary School gym, 9611 Westmoreland Road, Cornelius.

    Thursday: 7 p.m., Gaston Day School auditorium, 2001 Gaston Day School Road, Gastonia.

  • “Why is it important to me? We are running out of money. Seventy-two million baby boomers are all going to line up in 5 to 6 years for Medicare and their Social Security. The Chinese are going to run out of money.”

    Calvert Pelletier, 65, retired, Charlotte, carrying sign that favored public option, Independent

    “Parts of the (health care) system need fixing. Most of the government can agree on 50 percent. So let's fix the 50 percent we agree on and leave government out of it. The government tends to break things.”

    Nathan Hopper, 52, real estate appraiser, Monroe, Republican

    “The spending is what I'm concerned about. It's going to be going on for generations.”

    Patti Lutz, 47, Wesley Chapel, Republican, homemaker

    “I'm disappointed that our representatives think that we're mobs and people hired to be out here. When you look out here what do you see? I don't see any hired mobs. I see concerned citizens young and old.”

    Richard Kincaid, 60, Charlotte, dentist, Republican

  • Today: 7 p.m., J.V. Washam Elementary School gym, 9611 Westmoreland Road, Cornelius.

    Thursday: 7 p.m., Gaston Day School auditorium, 2001 Gaston Day School Road, Gastonia.


WEDDINGTON More that 1,200 people crowded into Weddington High School Tuesday night for a boisterous town hall meeting that evoked passionate sentiments not only about health care, but also immigration and the Obama administration.

“It's not about covering the uninsured in this country, it seems to me it's all about control,” Union County businessman Tony Mangum said, voice breaking. “I get emotional because I fear we're losing this country.”

A crowd that filled the school auditorium and overflowed into the cafeteria came out for the first of three town halls this week hosted by U.S. Rep. Sue Myrick of Charlotte.

Myrick, a Republican, opened the gathering by outlining her own opposition to Democratic health care bills and support for alternatives, including tax credits and continued reliance on the markets.

Across the country, such meetings have evoked strong feelings, particularly among opponents of a health care overhaul.

Myrick appealed for mutual respect as dozens of people lined up to speak. For the most part, the crowd obliged. But the audience jeered one critic whom sheriff's deputies escorted out after he called the crowd “the rudest he'd ever seen.”

Most speakers who came to the suburban school shared Myrick's opposition to proposals from the Obama administration and Democratic-controlled Congress.

One man described himself as part of the “silent majority.”

“The alarm sounded in my head with the stimulus bill,” he said, “Liberals would have you believe (the health care overhaul) is for the benefit of all. That's hogwash. It's a power grab, pure and simple.”

Others said they worry about the prospect of “socialized medicine.” A retired man said he was “petrified” about the direction of the country, including this week's decision to investigate CIA interrogations.

“I'm just concerned about where America's going,” he said. “I'm worried that we're going to be ruled by a foreign country in 30 years.”

One woman who identified herself as a nurse described what she called abuse of the system by Medicaid patients, particularly in the emergency room. “When something is free it's taken advantage of,” she said.

Others said they don't want illegal immigrants getting free health care. The proposals being negotiated in Congress do not provide coverage for illegal immigrants.

Critics also spoke up. One man noted the rise in the cost of health care and insurance.

“Why don't you abandon partisan posturing and put the good of your constituents ahead of entrenched business interests?”

“First of all I haven't been doing ‘partisan posturing,'” Myrick replied, “because this (health care) bill was written completely by Democrats.”

Another man asked Myrick if she opposes the federally funded health care programs of Medicare and Medicaid.

“You can't be on both sides,” he said.

Throughout the lengthy meeting, Myrick listened patiently, tamping down jeers, listening to critics and applauding people for being involved.

“You're the government,” she said. “I work for you.”

One woman upset with health care reform and President Obama said, “We have a beer-drinking, cigarette-smoking, name-calling president. America is upset and we're not going to back down.”

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

The Charlotte Observer welcomes your comments on news of the day. The more voices engaged in conversation, the better for us all, but do keep it civil. Please refrain from profanity, obscenity, spam, name-calling or attacking others for their views.   Read more

Disclaimer