Latest News

Climate bill has unlikely ally

The U.S. Senate is scheduled to cast a historic vote today on the first comprehensive global warming bill to make its way out of a committee room.

The sweeping legislation is expected to die.

But among those supporting the measure will be Sen. Elizabeth Dole, the Salisbury Republican whose voting record is among the Senate's most conservative.

“It's very important that we move on this because the costs of inaction are just too great,” Dole said Thursday. “The data became more and more voluminous.”

Her eureka moment, she said, came more than a year ago, after poring over the science about climate change and concluding that the Earth definitely is getting warmer.

Two colleagues on the Armed Services Committee – Independent Joe Lieberman of Connecticut and Republican John Warner of Virginia – persuaded her about the effect of climate change on national security.

She became one of just a handful of Republicans to support the bill, which allows companies to “buy” credits in exchange for emitting carbon. She says the bill would lessen the country's dependence on foreign oil.

“We're almost 60 percent dependent on foreign sources of oil, and look at where it comes from: Russia, the Middle East, Venezuela,” she said.

Most members of her party and many Democrats, too, oppose the legislation, in part because they have not been allowed to offer amendments.

But Jeremy Symons, national director of the National Wildlife Federation's global warming program, said he thinks more Republicans are beginning to sign on to the idea of fighting climate change.

“Senator Dole stepping forward to promote action on global warming had national ramifications,” Symons said. “I'm witnessing right now a transformation of the policy on climate change. Senator Dole stepping out has been a big part of that.”

Critic: Bill is ‘a Ponzi scheme'

Sen. Richard Burr, a Winston-Salem Republican, opposes the bill. He says it would do more to hurt the southeastern U.S. than any other part of the country because it targets coal-powered plants.

“It's a Ponzi scheme,” Burr said. “As long as you can find someone you can buy a credit from, you can continue to emit.”

The bill isn't expected to get the 60 votes needed today to move ahead, leaving it effectively dead for the year. But many environmentalists hope it will lay the groundwork for discussions in 2009.

Dole knows her support surprised a few people, but she said she has been interested in climate change since the first part of her Senate career.

“I certainly have made it known where I stand on this,” Dole said.

She also worked behind the scenes last fall to help shape the bill into one more palatable to some of her core constituencies, including manufacturers and other business interests.

Among the changes was the establishment of a tariff threat on foreign companies that don't lower their carbon outputs to the level of American companies, an effort to keep manufacturers competitive.

Some of Dole's work won't please all environmental groups, but Symons said a broad coalition will have to include business interests for climate change legislation to pass.

Components of the measure

The bill, known as the Climate Security Act, includes provisions for a variety of special interests, from job-training funds for renewable energy workers to funding for green buildings.

At its heart, though, the bill is a basic cap-and-trade system for energy companies that emit greenhouse gases. Companies such as coal plants would have a cap – which would be reduced over time – on how much they could send into the atmosphere. To exceed the limit, companies would have to purchase “credits” to go over the limit – the trade – including some from farmers and foresters who use environmentally friendly agriculture methods.

The bill has been endorsed by environmental groups, labor groups and several utility companies. Others, such as Duke Energy, have lobbied hard against it.

“I hope (Dole) will keep on track in keeping this thing moving forward,” said Jane Preyer, director of the N.C. chapter of the Environmental Defense Fund, a prime supporter of the bill.

Climate as security issue

In a Senate floor speech Tuesday, Dole hammered her main theme about why she supports the bill.

“I understand this bill is viewed by most as an environmental bill – which it is – but it is also essential to our national security,” she said.

She also said the bill had flaws in not focusing more on nuclear energy and not pushing for domestic oil and gas exploration. How much of Dole's climate change work will roll into her re-election effort remains to be seen.

Asked whether she thought global warming would be part of her campaign, Dole said she thinks voters may be focused on other issues.

“Obviously it's something I'll talk about from time to time because it's a major issue that we face, but in terms of what people ask about, I think frankly the immigration issue will be talked about a lot more,” Dole said.

Rival Hagan supports bill

Her Democratic opponent, state Sen. Kay Hagan of Greensboro, supports the bill, which her spokeswoman said fit Hagan's energy plan offered this spring.

Hagan's spokeswoman, Colleen Flanagan, criticized Dole's sincerity on climate change, saying that Dole has taken campaign contributions in the past from the oil and gas industry.

  Comments