Health & Family

FDA's handling of tomato issue being scrutinized

Turf struggles, bad communication and weak leadership undermined the federal response to a recent salmonella outbreak that cost the tomato industry a bundle, witnesses told a House of Representatives subcommittee Thursday.

Lawmakers joined farmers in a wholesale attack on the Food and Drug Administration's performance, potentially laying the political foundation for a regulatory overhaul and multimillion-dollar compensation package.

“We have been the primary injured party,” Reginald Brown, the executive vice president of the Florida Tomato Growers Exchange, told the House panel, “and we look forward to Congress addressing that in the future.”

Farmers say that the FDA and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention erred in indicating that the salmonella outbreak was associated with tomatoes. State regulators testified that the FDA shared information reluctantly, while produce industry representatives complained that no one seemed to be in charge.

“We've noticed tensions (and) rivalries” among federal food-safety agencies, United Fresh Produce Association President Thomas Stenzel told the House Energy and Commerce Committee's oversight and investigations panel.

Federal food-safety officials still decline to exonerate tomatoes, although they say that fresh tomatoes currently on the market are safe. FDA Assistant Commissioner David Acheson stressed Thursday that the initial reported illnesses were “statistically linked to consumption of raw tomatoes,” although no tainted tomatoes were found.

More than 1,300 U.S. residents have been sickened by the salmonella Saintpaul strain in the past three months. At least 252 people have been hospitalized in 43 states, and two have died.

The FDA warned consumers nationwide June 7 against three types of tomatoes thought to be possibly implicated in the outbreak. The agency lifted its warning July 17. Investigators subsequently have traced salmonella to jalapeno and serrano peppers grown on two Mexican ranches.

Last week, eight Florida lawmakers introduced a bill authorizing $100 million in compensation for growers.

  Comments