First, the $700billion rescue for the economy was about buying devalued mortgage-backed securities from tottering banks to unclog frozen credit markets.
Then it was about using $250billion of it to buy stakes in banks. The idea was that banks would use the money to start making loans again.
But reports surfaced that bankers might instead use the money to buy other banks, pay dividends, give employees a raise and executives a bonus, or just sit on it. Insurance companies now want a piece; maybe automakers, too, even though Congress has approved $25 billion in low-interest loans for them.
Three weeks after becoming law, and with the first dollar of the $700 billion yet to go out, officials are just beginning to talk about helping strapped homeowners keep the foreclosure wolf from the door.
As the crisis worsens, the government's reaction keeps changing. Lawmakers in both parties are starting to gripe that the bailout is turning out to be far different from what the Bush administration sold to Congress.
In buying equity stakes in banks, the Treasury has “deviated significantly from its original course,” says Alabama Sen. Richard Shelby, the top Republican on the Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee.
The centerpiece of the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act is the “troubled asset relief program,” or TARP. Critics note that tarps are used to cover things up. The money was to be devoted to buying “toxic” mortgage-backed securities whose value has fallen in lockstep with home prices.
But once European governments said they were going into the banking business, Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson followed suit and diverted $250 billion to buy stock in healthy banks to spur lending.
Bank executives hinted they might instead use it for acquisitions. Sen. Chris Dodd, chairman of the Senate banking committee, said this development was “beyond troubling.”
Sure enough, a day after Dodd, D-Conn., made the comment, the government confirmed that PNC Financial Services Group was approved to receive $7.7 billion in return for company stock. At the same time, PNC said it was acquiring National City for $5.58 billion.
“Although there will be some consolidation, that's not the driver behind this program,” Paulson recently told talk-show host Charlie Rose. “The driver is to have our healthy banks be well-capitalized so that they can play the role they need to play for our country right now.”