It wasn’t quite “Call me Ishmael,” but “Call me Caitlyn” made a whale of a splash.
One could hardly find a news channel this week that wasn’t touting the former Bruce Jenner for her courageous transgender metamorphosis or admiring Caitlyn Jenner’s “gorgeous” new look on the cover of Vanity Fair’s July issue.
Before proceeding, let’s stipulate that we wish Jenner the best. It must be terribly difficult to find oneself not at home in one’s own physical and societally recognized self.
What concerns me here is the cultural, primarily media, treatment of the Jenner case in particular – and the assumption that we all need to be a part of this.
Sign Up and Save
Get six months of free digital access to The Charlotte Observer
From the interview in April with Diane Sawyer, to the Vanity Fair cover, to the breathless media coverage this week, one’s overwhelming sense is that Caitlyn Jenner – and only incidentally, transgenderism – is the Next New Thing!
Every movement needs a celebrity, and Jenner is the self-appointed transgender community’s poster girl. But is Jenner really the best face for such a profound experience, no offense to her plastic surgeon?
Though many of us remember Jenner as the stunning 1976 Olympic decathlon gold medalist, the erstwhile Wheaties model is best-known to a younger generation as Dad in the reality television series “Keeping Up with the Kardashians.”
To put it bluntly, the former Bruce and the latter Caitlyn have been media personalities-for-hire for most of their existence. Is it really appropriate to elevate Jenner to such heroic and adjectival heights as “bold” and “courageous,” when many transgender people will conduct their own struggles privately, and, indeed, courageously?
Caitlyn, like Bruce, seems to need the applause of an audience as much as she needs the transformation itself.
This is not to suggest that Jenner’s transgender identity is anything but heartfelt and necessary. As we learn more about transgender issues – and presumably education is the nobler intention driving media attention – it becomes less easy to ignore such people or deny them equal protections under the law.
But I’ve learned more about transgender individuals and their families from the tender poetry of Sue Ellen Thompson than from magazine displays and televised hype. In her latest collection, “They,” Thompson writes lovingly of her own transgender daughter’s journey and the challenges her evolution poses for her family. I commend her book to those interested in insight over titillation.
In stark contrast, seeing Jenner all gussied up like some 1940s Vargas girl (part Madonna, part Kardashian?) – wearing long tresses and corset-inspired lingerie – seems a mockery of her new womanhood, as well as the human dignity her public outing purportedly is intended to inspire.
All of the above suggests much psychological and emotional work left to do, for which Jenner surely deserves privacy rather than spectacle. She has averred that with the Vanity Fair cover, she is “finally free.” One would hope the same for the rest of us, but, alas. A new E! reality show following Jenner’s progress as a woman is in the works.
Cue the audience.