Columns & Blogs

Steve Smith release hearkens back to Bobcats’ Gerald Wallace trade

I’ve watched from afar as Carolina Panthers fans raged over the team’s decision to part ways with wide receiver Steve Smith. The reaction reminded me of how Charlotte Bobcats fans felt betrayed when Gerald Wallace was traded to the Portland Trail Blazers.

A perfect analogy? No. Smith was part of a Super Bowl team and went to several Pro Bowls. Wallace played in one playoff series in Charlotte and represented the Bobcats in one NBA All-Star Game.

But here’s where the analogy holds: Wallace was the closest thing the Bobcats had to an iconic player, a singular reason to attend home games. Smith and Wallace both have maverick attitudes about expressing themselves forcefully, even if that riled management.

So here’s my advice to Panthers fans: Vent your anger; mourn the loss of No. 89. But don’t be so driven by emotion as to ignore the possibility this could work out OK in the end.

Because that’s what happened with the Wallace trade.

The Bobcats effectively traded Wallace for two future first-round picks (the player exchange was mostly for cap purposes). The fans hated it and it put then-interim coach Paul Silas in a no-win situation.

But history proved the front office dealt Wallace in advance of some severe physical decline. He’s been traded twice since leaving Charlotte. Now, by his own admission, “Crash” is a reserve making $9.2 million this season and next. He’s done for the season with the Boston Celtics following knee and ankle surgeries.

My point: Wallace and Smith did some great things athletically in this town that pulled fans out of their seats. Now Smith is somewhere in the same vicinity Wallace was when the Bobcats traded him: closer to the end than the beginning and not quite the playmaker he once was.

Fans do and should cherish a player for what he’s done. In contrast, it’s a front office’s responsibility to judge what that player will do and act on it.

Not saying the Panthers made the right call, because I don’t know all the circumstances – none of us do. But this isn’t blasphemy, either. It’s business.

Five passing thoughts on the NBA and the Bobcats:

Related stories from Charlotte Observer