Latest News

In the battle of electric scooters vs. bikes in Charlotte, one is clearly winning

Charlotteans seem to prefer scooting to pedaling.

Both dockless bikes and scooters have exploded in popularity in recent months, with riders zipping around uptown, South End and other close-in neighborhoods. But the latest numbers from the pilot program show electric scooter use has quickly outpaced shared bikes, with scooter users riding more and riding farther.

Their soaring popularity has also prompted more calls for regulation and worries about safety, helmet-less riders and pedestrians being bowled over. At least one major employer, Duke Energy, has barred its employees from using scooters during work hours.

“Even though these items can be tempting to use as a fun, fast means of getting from one location to another, there is also a tremendous amount of risk associated with operating them,” said Duke Energy spokesman Neil Nissan. “Whether they’re walking, riding a bike or driving a car, we’ve asked them to be on the lookout for more people using rental bicycles and scooters.”

A Charlotte Department of Transportation spokeswoman declined to comment about safety issues and referred comment to the companies. The CDOT representative said no information was available about injuries reported so far from scooter use, though the department encourages riders to wear helmets and carefully plan their routes.

“As more and more people rely on and adapt to scooter sharing, we believe that along with proactive education, safe riding and responsible use will ultimately become a natural habit,” said Mary Caroline Pruitt, a spokeswoman for Lime. She pointed out that the company instructs riders to wear helmets with notices through the app and reminders on the scooter itself.

“Safety is our number one priority, and Lime urges riders to always put the safety of others and themselves before anything else when operating any of our vehicles.”

Both the bikes and scooters are operating as part of a pilot program under an agreement with the city that ends this fall. Last November, 2,000 dockless bikes from four companies — Ofo, Lime, Mobike and Spin — hit the Charlotte streets.

One of the companies, Ofo, pulled out of Charlotte in July and several other U.S. cities this year after the company said it had “begun to re-evaluate markets that present obstacles,” without citing specific reasons.

scooter secondary
People riding scooters are zipping along Charlotte sidewalks and streets past pedestrians and sometimes in lanes of traffic. John D. Simmons jsimmons@charlotteobserver.com

The scooter companies, Bird and Lime, are each allowed to operate up to 400 scooters in Charlotte, under a pilot program that started in late May.

In just a few months, the number of scooter rides has outpaced the number of bike rides. While bikes require pedaling, balancing and, in the summer, sweating, electric scooters propel riders at faster speeds with the flick of a thumb lever.

As of July, people in Charlotte had ridden electric scooters more than 174,000 times, according to the Charlotte Department of Transportation, compared to approximately 173,264 dockless bike rides. That’s despite the bikes having been available in Charlotte for nine months versus less than three for the scooters and there being almost twice as many bikes available.

The data for July, the most recent month available, show bike users took 27,453 trips and rode 19,430 miles.

Electric scooters, on the other hand, accounted for 100,273 trips and a whopping 139,215 miles in the same month.

The average scooter user rode 1.42 miles and spent 13 minutes per ride, according to CDOT. Bikes were ridden an average of about 3/4 miles, with average trip lengths of nine minutes.

Unlike previous bike-sharing options, users leave dockless bikes and scooters wherever they want when their ride is done, and the next user finds their ride with a GPS-enabled app. Riders rent them with an app on their phone.

The bikes and scooters typically cost $1 to unlock, and additional charges are based on the time rented, with scooters costing 15 cents per minute and the bikes costing $1 per hour or 30 minutes.

After the pilot program ends, Charlotte City Council could consider regulations ranging from banning the companies, requiring them to pay permitting fees, limiting the number of operators allowed in the city or restricting where riders can go.

Despite their popularity, the companies have faced questions about regulation and safety.

Riders often don’t wear helmets and are sometimes on sidewalks or in traffic. The electric scooters can top 20 mph going downhill. Bicycles are sometimes left blocking sidewalks, in private yards or even dumped in creeks and ponds.

20180828_112840.jpg
The controls for a Bird scooter, showing the QR code to unlock the scooter, the brake, a thumb-push accelerator and a bell to warn pedestrians. Ely Portillo


20180828_112832.jpg
The controls for a Lime scooter, showing the QR code to scan and the thumb-push accelerator to operate the throttle. Ely Portillo

The scooter companies prompted even more regulatory questions when they started leaving their dockless electric vehicles around the city without permission. Initially, Charlotte officials told them they had to remove their scooters or face confiscation. But the city agreed in the pilot program to see how they would work.

Council member Larken Egleston said Monday that he’s worried about safety. He said he saw a couple riding an electric scooter on Interstate 277 this weekend.

“Someone will die on an e-scooter before the end of this calendar year,” he predicted. “We’ve got to have some rules in place.”

Bird didn’t respond to messages seeking more information Tuesday.

20180828_112755 (1).jpg
Bird and Lime scooters lined up on South Caldwell Street in uptown Charlotte. Ely Portillo
Portillo: 704-358-5041
  Comments