Five Below's Silly $5 Find Brings a Playful Twist to Pet Toys
The problem with shopping at Five Below is that once you're done shopping for yourself, there's always the urge to take a peek at the pet section before leaving. With everything from sports-themed cat scratchers to stylish dog bowl sets, adorable socks, toys and more under one roof, every visit turns up something intriguing you'll want to bring home.
This week's new obsession? A duo of snack-themed dog toys any good boy or girl would be excited to add to their collection. Sporting a cool $5 price tag and available in both Claussen Pickle and Oreo styles, the Licensed Pet Plush Toy is your furry friend's ticket to hours of fun with a toy that looks just like a couple of foods that are usually totally off-limits.
SIGN UP to get "pawsitivity" delivered right to your inbox with inspiring & entertaining stories about our furry & feathered friends
Licensed Pet Plush Toy, $5 at Five Below
Located at the magical place where tail wagging meets lip-smacking fun, these adorable plush toys are a must-have in the house, on road trips, visits to see family and more. Designed with a squeaker inside, each one features a different type of texture fit to match their unique shape. At $5 a piece, they're equally great for your little one as it is the perfect gift for any dog-loving friend.
Available both in-store and online, shoppers can choose from Claussen Pickle and Oreo designs, both of which your fur baby will be more than excited to dig their teeth into. The Claussen Pickle features a classic pickle shape, plump and bumpy for extra texture, along with a soft fuzz that offers a satisfying bite. It also features a cute smile paired with cartoonish eyes, plus the classic Claussen logo across the front.
Related: Five Below's Whimsical $7 Find Brings Iconic Animal Fun to Summer Pool Parties
A Variety of Textures for Every Play Style
The Oreo toy, on the other hand, features the familiar Oreo cookie shape, complete with a bite taken out of it and classic Oreo branding. The cookie has a tougher exterior than the pickle, making it a solid option for tough chewers, while the "bite" section is made from soft white fabric, creating a dual-texture design your pup will love to explore.
With two solid toy options available at the same $5 price point, these adorable plush picks are a no-brainer for anyone looking to elevate playtime for their furry friend. And when it comes to dog toys, texture isn't just a bonus, it's a big part of the appeal. Different materials can keep pups engaged longer, giving them something new to chew, tug and explore instead of losing interest after a few sessions.
While Five Below doesn't specify the exact size of each toy, styles like these are typically best suited for small to medium-sized dogs. That said, the retailer has been known to carry multiple size variations, so larger pups may get their turn soon. In the meantime, these snack-inspired finds are an easy add to your cart, and worth checking out alongside Five Below's Rockin' Bull Pool Float and whimsical dog training kit.
Related: Pet Parents Are Raving About Aldi's Cute and Stylish $7 Rainy Day Essential
Copyright 2026 The Arena Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved
This story was originally published April 14, 2026 at 8:30 PM.