Analyst sends bold stock market message as S&P 500 hits new highs
TheS&P 500 is grinding higher, even as investors remain stuck in neutral.
In a recent sitdown interview with CNBC, veteran analyst Paul Hickey said that the stark gap is relevant because the market's message is much more optimistic than the headlines suggest.
For perspective, according to Reuters, the Nasdaq Composite closed at 24,016.02, up 1.6%, on April 15, 2026 (its 11th straight winning session).
Moreover, that day the S&P 500 closed at a new record of 7,022.95, leaving it around 9%below its prior record at the March low. By the next day, the Nasdaq stretched its incredible run to 12 straight gains, the longest since July 2009.
Nevertheless, Hickey didn't wave off the risks; instead, he laid out the case that the data simply don't line up with the doom-and-gloom narrative.
The big banks are still posting superb loan growth.
At the same time, unemployment remains low, andjobless claims aren't flashing a panic signal. On top of that, the Fed's latest read on regional activity still points to more growth than weakness.
For context, Paul Hickey is a popular numbers-first market strategist and co-founder of Bespoke Investment Group.
He's been at the helm of Mr. Market's more reputable independent research shops for 19 years, giving him real market pedigree.
Moreover, he worked under veteran Wall Street bull Laszlo Birinyi, gaining experience across stocks, fixed income, and other key market products.
Also, he has featured regularly as a guest on CNBC and other prominent financial media outlets over the past decade.
That said, as Hickey puts it, the markets are forward-looking, and they already show that worst-case fears haven't materialized in the real economy.
Additionally, as analysts dial back their forecasts, even a relatively robust earnings season looks better than feared.
Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images
Wall Street price targets for the S&P 500
- Morgan Stanley: 7,800.
- Citigroup: 7,700.
- Barclays: 7,650.
- Goldman Sachs: 7,600.
- UBS Global Wealth Management: 7,500.
- J.P. Morgan: 7,200.
- Bank of America Global Research: 7,100.
What's behind Paul Hickey's bullish market call
Hickey, in acknowledging the risks, feels investors are misreading them.
More Wall Street
- Top analyst bets these stocks will boost your portfolio in 2026
- Bank of America sends quiet warning to stock market investors
He framed the recent rally as "just optimism" that markets are speeding towards clarity, even though there's nothing conclusive to go on.
Additionally, he feels that "the underlying economy has been very strong," which explains why stocks continue to climb rather than buckle under pressure.
His logic rests on a few big pillars:
- The real economy still looks sturdy. Hickey said bank results showed loan expansion "up 10 year-over-year," indicating demand hasn't fallen apart. Also, the unemployment rate is still low at 4.3%, and jobless claims remain contained.
- Earnings fears may be overdone. Hickey argues that this reporting season is less backward-looking and more about guidance.
He bets that investors might get "more benign reports" than expected, especially as analysts trim forecasts, creating room for solid upside surprises. - Leadership is coming from the right places. Hickey said that chip stocks are the "transports of the 21st century," calling them the core indicator for the digital economy. With chip stocks and AI infrastructure names still making new highs, he feels that Mr.Market's most dominant theme is intact.
Put simply, though the headlines are still scary, the data and the market action point to a cleaner story.
Why the economy still looks tougher than the headlines
Hickey's point about the economy is well taken and backed by recent data.
Though the headlines have been noisy, the hard data point to a more resilient economy, spearheaded by strong lending patterns and lower layoffs.
- Banks are still lending. Commercial and industrial loans at U.S. commercial banks jumped to nearly $2.83 trillion in March, up substantially from $2.68 trillion a year earlier.
The big banks point to a similar story: Wells Fargo said loans jumped 11% year-over-year in Q1, while Citi said average loans grew 9%. - The labor market is cooling, not cracking. The March unemployment rate held relatively steady at 4.3%, while the U.S. still added 178,000 jobs.
- Layoffs are still low.Initial jobless claims dropped to 207,000 for the week ended April 11, while the four-week moving average came in at 209,750.
- The Fed's survey still leans positive.The April Beige Book said that activity rose at a slight-to-modest pace in 8 of 12 districts. On top of that, loan demand held up, with labor demand relatively stable.
S&P 500 year-end closes
- 2020: 3,756.07
- 2021: 4,766.18
- 2022: 3,839.50
- 2023: 4,769.83
- 2024: 5,906.94
- 2025: 6,845.50
Source: Yahoo Finance
Related: Goldman Sachs just found a reason to like Nvidia stock again
The Arena Media Brands, LLC THESTREET is a registered trademark of TheStreet, Inc.
This story was originally published April 19, 2026 at 10:33 AM.